very clever and tragic
|
|
recommend this book, is extremely clever wry look into "society" and shallow, superficial types who are only concerned with what people wear and how much money they have. Lily (central character) turning to all sorts of odious men to keep up appearances and money, while her true love is laid aside, feelings counting little in this character's world. As a christian i find this book quite revelant as it demonstrates how little money and good time friends mean as the outcome reveals. Very good, not excellent, but v good, ethan frome by the same author is superior for me
|
|
Fascinating look at 19th Century New York Society
|
"The heart of the wise is in the house of mourning, but the heart of fools is in the house of mirth" Ecclesiastes 7:4 KJV. Hence begins the story of Lily Bart, raised from birth with no other purpose in life than to be a beautiful ornament to society. Lily is left with little money of her own and must rely on family and friends until she can make an advantageous marriage. Unfortunately, she makes some poor choices in life which diminish her social status, which eventually leads her to attempts to eke out a living among the working class.
Wharton, who grew up in this same environment, pulls no punches. We see both the glamour and richness of late 19th century New York society, along with it's evil underside. Wharton's prose is glorious, but you have to pay attention and not wander or you'll end up back tracking and reading that paragraph again so as not to miss the story, you want to slow down and enjoy it like a fine red wine or a box of chocolate (or both). If you enjoy classic literature with a soap opera melodramatic tone to it (like Hardy's Tess), this should be right up your alley. So many times Lily and Seldon missed their opportunity for happiness! Have the hanky ready for the last chapters, you'll need it.
|
|
Fabulous but frustrating
|
|
I enjoyed the first half of this book enormously. It is beautifully written, capturing the glitter and shallowness of the fashionable world in a slightly Fitzgeraldian way. Lily Bart is supposed to be one of the most engaging heroines in all of fiction, and for much of the book this is certainly true. The complexity of her conflicting emotions and desires is wonderfully expressed. Towards the second half of the book, I started to lose sympathy with her, against my will. The main theme of the novel is her struggle to put morality over expediency and pragmatism, and the fact that she does so is seen as an overmastering triumph, "saving herself whole from the ruin of her life." I found it impossible not to wish she would just compromise her morality - the compromise required hardly seems an significant one by today's standards - and provide a happy ending to her life instead of a disasterous one.
|
|
An acute observation of early twentieth-century US society
|
|
The House of Mirth is an anthropological subversion of the Emersonian ideal - that anyone might be able to escape from a materialist world determined by social considerations, through a philosophy of self-reliance. Wharton asks the pressing question: how can a woman journey away from the world of domesticity and oppressive conformity, when her need is to forge a place for herself within society, not to escape from it? Ishmael and Huck Finn sought a watery world away from the female, who symbolised society and bondage, but Lily Bart can never undertake such a process of alienation: she is, she admits, 'useless' in all respects other than her value as a commodity in the marriage market, where she excels. Thus loneliness wears heavily on Lily when she finds herself ousted from her community - a result of her own carelessness, and slurs against her from those who see her as a threat. I say The House of Mirth is anthropological, in the sense that it is a literary precedent for what would later become known as cultural determinism; that is, the conception that human conduct is directed by environmental / biological factors of which we may be largely unconscious. It is not surprising to discover that Wharton read Darwin and Zola intensively in her early twenties. Lily Bart is herself engaged in a competition with her rivals to find the wealthiest husband, in what amounts to a 'survival of the fittest' - although the 'winners' in Wharton's world are not necessarily those most physically or economically strong, but rather those who best conform to the all-powerful social structure, and secure a physical space in society (normally, a home). Those who fail to adapt, whether due to social background, or - in Lily's case - pyschological temperament - are doomed. Thus an important ambiguity is created: whether it is better to forsake morality and independence in order to improve one's social status, or whether a moral victory is ultimately more profitable than a material one. Wharton leaves any such conclusion to the reader. If I have made The House of Mirth sound drearily scientific, rest assured this is not the case: it reads much like a novel by Austen or Eliot, but with a sharper tinge of social satire. I would say it is perhaps a little long, and that the determinism implicit in the character of Lily Bart renders the outcome a little inevitable, but it does have some brilliant moments: the best of these being the tête-à -tête between Lily and Selden in chapter 6; a meditation on spiritual independence and moral cowardice which will colour the rest of the novel. And it is a curious book in that it has no real heroes, but rather a series of characters who are all crucially flawed in some way, and who do little to resolve these flaws until it is too late. It is thus a novel of realism, of a perverse Providence, and centrally, of the unstoppable power of the dollar in refashioning the class system: something from which the earliest Americans had been determined to liberate themselves.
|
|
Excellent Book from an Excellent Author
|
|
I have read a lot of Edith Wharton (Age of Innocence, The House of Mirth, Ethan Frome, etc.), and I can say I love this book the best. The story captivates and wrenches your heart while the commentary, subtle at nearly all times, rings true even today. The story follows the beautiful Lily Bart as she painfully falls out of the graces of society by, unfortunately, her own fault and naivete. Rather than cursing her foolishness as one would normally do, the reader feels strong empathy for a woman who, much to her own detriment, simply does not know how to live in the real world; she trusts too much, thinks too little, and feels too deeply. I will, of course, not ruin the ending for you, but I will say, if you have a heart, it will break. The commentary, on the other hand, is scathing, and critics and the public of her time took it quite personally, much like Theodore Dreiser's public later took Sister Carrie. The idea of a woman being treated as an object was everyday in Lily's time, but the public certainly didn't want to hear about it. Old though the book may be, Lily's plight and the message connected still hit home. I will also recommend watching the film adaptation of the book, starring Gillian Anderson, who plays Lily Bart in a way that makes me proud. I adored her already as an X-Files fan, and I was astounded--literally ASTOUNDED--when I watched her as Lily. Read the book, then watch Gillian. You won't regret the 140 minutes you spend with the video. Happy reading.
|
|
|