Last Citadel by David L. Robbins, , 0553801775 Search discount cheap book, Compare Book prices, Find Lowest Price
 Compare book prices at 85 bookstores
Add to Favorite Tell a Friend Link to Us Contact Us Help Home Wish List New!
us online discount book stores United States | canada online books for less Canada | Rare/Out-of-print Books

Last Citadel, cheap new, used books  Last Citadel: A Novel of the Battle of Kursk
Author: David L Robbins  
ISBN: 0553801775   /   Hardcover
Publisher: Bantam Books   /   2003-08
List Price: £16.72
Similar Books   More Details from Amazon.co.uk
Compare new, used book prices

Customer Reviews:
How not to write historical fiction....     
The Germans are lean and mean, only wanting to kill. The Russians are a fun loving lot who hate the Commies but hate the Nazis more and are thus forced to fight to protect their beloved homeland from the fascist hordes who, unprovoked, have wreaked havoc etc etc etc.

I bought this at an airport three years ago as I have always had an interest in Kursk and I still haven't finished it and probably won't as it's impossible to take an interest in the central casting cast (fanatical Spaniard, grizzled Cossack etc). In fact one of the most entertaining things to do with it is to play guess the next cliché!

Once more another half-digested pile of facts is poured out in novel form. The technical details of the weaponry are very good but the tanks themselves have more character than the humans who are so stock it defies belief. I feel the author would have done better writing a short military primer, either on the battle or the tanks, rather than attempting to write a novel, something for which he clearly has little feel or talent.
Mediocre Miltiary/Historical Fiction     
I've never read any of Robbins other books, but I'd heard good things about The War of the Rats, so I thought I'd give this a go. I knew very little about the Battle of Kursk and my knowledge of the Eastern Front in general is somewhat shaky (although I did read and enjoy Guy Sajer's memoir The Forgotten Soldier). By the end of this book, it struck me that it's very much like a lot of historical and military fiction: decent at getting across the salient facts, decent at putting the reader in the middle of the action, woeful at pacing, characterization, drama, and woodenly written.

The story revolves around the pivotal battle in July 1943 for the Soviet city of Kursk. Around two million soldiers were arrayed against each other, along with the largest collection of tanks ever seen. A German offensive, code named "Citadel", was an attempt by Hitler to create a breakthrough in Russia before he would be forced to reallocate troops and tanks to deal with the impending American invasion of Italy. The protagonists are a Spanish SS Panzer officer and a Russian family, two of whom serve in the same T-34 tank. The Spaniard is the son of a famous Barcelonan bullfighter and is part of the "Blue Division" sent by Franco to fight with the Germans. A sniper shot outside Leningrad took him out of action for almost a year and turned him into a pale, shriveled shell of what he used to be. Now he's back, escorting a final shipment of Tiger tanks to the front lines, and looking for revenge, honor, and glory to sustain the rest of his years. If this isn't cheesy enough, we have on the opposite side, the Berko family. Of Cossack linage, the cartoonish father is a tank driver for his son, a serious and distant Communist, while the daughter is a fearless member of an all-female night bomber unit. Supporting cardboard-thin characters include a gung-ho SS tank commander, a series of Ukrainian partisans, a noble Russian pilot, and a German intelligence officer spying for the Russians.

On the German side, the story mostly consists of Vega safeguarding the transport of a final shipment of Tiger tanks to the front and eventually being assigned to command one of them in the battle. On the Russian side, we have the two Berko men in their latest T-34, dealing with two new recruits and preparing for the battle. Their daughter/sister, meanwhile, is engaged on nightly bombing runs. However, when her male pilot friend gets shot down, she naturally tries to rescue him, resulting in her getting absorbed into a partisan unit with a traitor in its midst. Naturally, by the end, Vega and the Berkos will meet on the field of battle and dance their inevitable dance. Many of the story elements are poorly handled and are utterly lacking in drama or tension, such as the woman's love interest, the subplot about the traitor, and most especially the German officer spy. In contrast, the actual tactical and technical details come across rather well. Robbins does a very clear job of explaining the relative strengths and weaknesses of every tank. Similarly, he does a very good job of recreating the noise, smells, and confusion of simply driving a tank. The battle scenes are very capably handled, and one gets a reasonable impression of what it might have been like. The problem is that none of the characters are compelling or convincing, and therefore it's impossible to care very much about what happens to them.

This is military and historical fiction at its most mediocre, it's not awful, just not good. It's the kind of book I might have liked a lot when I was 16 or 17, but seems awfully thin as an adult. To be fair to Robbins, I'm not really sure how you could really make a massive tank battle that compelling to begin with. If one really is really interested in the battle, I'd suggest skipping this and checking out a decent web resource called "Battle of Kursk On the Web" that has tons of links.

Götterdämmerung amidst the sunflowers     
In a previous historical novel, THE WAR OF THE RATS, author David Robbins took us to the 1942 siege of Stalingrad on World War Two's Eastern Front, one usually paid scant attention by American readers who perhaps believe that U.S. won the European war single-handed. It didn't, you know. Now, in LAST CITADEL, Robbins returns to the Eastern Front for history's greatest tank battle.

It's July 1943, and Hitler throws one last roll of the dice against the USSR with a major armored offensive designed to capture the city of Kursk. America is about to invade Italy, and Germany must knock the Soviets out of the war, or at least stabilize that front, before having to withdraw some of its forces from the East to reinforce the Mediterranean theater.

Whereas in THE WAR OF THE RATS, the confrontation in Stalingrad's rubble was between two master snipers, one German and one Russian, the LAST CITADEL evolves into the ultimate confrontation in a field of sunflowers between two tank crews, one German in the awesome Tiger tank and one Russian in the smaller but faster T-34.

The Tiger is commanded by SS Captain Luis Ruiz de Vega of the 1st SS Panzergrenadiers, one of three SS armored divisions spearheading the German assault. De Vega originally came to fight for the Nazis with the Spanish Blue Division, lent to Hitler by Franco in 1941. Having lost half his stomach to a Russian sniper during the siege of Leningrad, de Vega was rewarded with a commission in the SS. Now, bitter, constantly hungry, increasingly emaciated, and emotionally dead, Luis dreams only of returning to Spain a war hero.

The T-34 is commanded by Sgt. Valentin Berko, but its soul is its driver, Cpl. Dimitri Berko, Valentin's father. Dimitri is an old Cossack who's fought against the Czar, Trotsky's Red Army, and now the Germans. The elder Berko loves his son dearly, but is disgusted with the latter's unquestioning dedication to Communism. But the two together make a formidable fighting team.

In THE WAR OF THE RATS, a five-star novel, subplots added to the overall storyline, especially as military sniping involves a lot of waiting for the perfect shot. In contrast, several subplots in LAST CITADEL only serve as unnecessary distractions. Dimitri's daughter, Katya, is a bomber pilot attached to the Night Witches, who fly biplanes so slow and flimsy that they can only operate at night. Her boyfriend, Leonid, also a pilot, but in a modern squadron, is shot down. Attempting a landing behind enemy lines to rescue him, Katya crashes, and subsequently falls in with a group of Russian partisans, which has an unidentified traitor in its midst. In the meantime, SS Colonel Abram Breit, is spying for the Soviet's Lucy network.

Had Robbins focused entirely on the tank engagements of the Kursk battle, his book, in my opinion, would have been leaner, meaner, and better. In any case, his description of going to war in the Tiger and T-34 makes for an absorbing and informative read.

Flawed but enjoyable...     
The latest World War Two faction novel from Robbins falls somehwere between the taut brilliance of 'War of the Rats' and the flaccid 'The End of War'. The tale is sporadically thrilling, but there are plenty of longeurs to slog through. Over-written and perhaps bogged down by an over adherence to hisitorical events, this is a not always succesful melange of fact and fiction. Characterisation is also patchy - like 'War of the Rats', his cast on the German side is more interesting psychologically and emotionally, than his Russians who appear more as paragons of virtue and not a little dull.

Worth reading, but could have been so much better if more rigorously edited. A good primer on WW2's Battle of Kursk, but as fiction flawed.

The biggest tank battle     
This latest novel by Robbins is a mildly entertaining read about the epic tank battle fought near Kursk in July 1943. On the plus side: he is well informed, using the latest information about the battle and not the myths we have been fed for years and the book is well written. Unfortunately, Robbins cannot quite make up his mind whether to give us the actual facts or write a novel. What I mean is: what readers did he have in mind? People like me who know all the facts will be bored by the rather stereotypical characters (disturbed SS-men, courageous Russians)and the predictable ending and readers who want an exciting read will be bored by all the facts. So: competently written, but not very thrilling. Hence: three out of five stars.
View more reviews or product details from Amazon.co.uk


 

            

 

Looking for Rare, Out of Print Books? Click here


About Us
 Recommend Us Bookmark Link To Us Wish List New!


us online discount book stores United States | buy uk books online United Kingdom | canada online books for less Canada

(c) 2004 BookFinder4u UK - Search Cheap new, used, out of print books.


Suggestion Box:
Let us know anything you like or don't like about this website.