Fairly interesting
|
I like McDevvitts work, and I thought Cauldron was entertaining. I did not feel it grabbed me like some of his other work in the same series, but there was still a sense of exploration. Sometimes, as I read, I found similarity with previous stories. McDevitt himself agrees that he recycles
ideas and almost whole tales - most notably in A Talent for War. But I think he is just being honest there - and probably lots of authors do this.
Caudron wraps up most of the Patricia Hutchins series in explaining the origin of the Omega Clouds. The book is really in two parts. the first is about a potential improvement on the star drive which will allow a trip towards the galactic centre. The second half is a stops-along-the-way adventure.
It is probably enjoyable for readers of the series. It may not stand alone.
|
|
Jack's Cauldron doesn't bubble
|
I discovered McDevitt only recently and rapidly read and enjoyed his 'catalogue'. I couldn't wait to get this new book to read more about Hutch and her world. I wish I hadn't bothered.
This McDevitt is slow - I'd read over 200 pages before the action started. He is very keen to reprise all the early story lines (Chindi, stealth satellites, Omega clouds) and complete them. Unfortunately I found all the completions unsatisfactory. As far as the Omega's were concerned, I believe the conclusion was scientifically challenged.
Pity - I was looking forward to it
|
|
|
United States | 
United Kingdom | 
Canada