Love this book!
|
What an amazing book! Brilliant, original idea, well played out - it had me panting for the next one in the series. There should be a law passed obliging Jasper fforde to write at least one Thursday Next book a year.
|
|
Over-long one-joke book
|
...which Woody Allen did better in "The Kugelmass Episode", a short story in his collection "Side Effects".
Not too terrible, though it dragged in places. I won't rush to read any more Fforde, though I might pick it up if there was nothing else around.
|
|
loved it
|
|
I loved this book if you want something to take you away from reality for a while this is the book especially if you like sci-fi novels terry pratchett etc.I couldnt put it down cant wait to read the others.
|
|
If you like a book that requires you to leave all sense of reality behind then this book is for you...
|
This is just my sort of book. The humour in it is just right, the action is well paced and the writing is clever. It's the sort of book where you have to leave all sense of reality behind because Fforde creates a familiar but completely different world in which the Crimean War is still raging after 131 years, genetic engineering has been taken to a new level and the lines between reality and fiction are soft. I don't want to spoil it too much because part the joy of this book is discovering all there is to discover about this parallel reality.
I consider myself to be well-read but I have to admit I haven't read `Jane Eyre'. Nor have I seen any TV or film adaptations of it so I'm not entirely sure how I knew the plot but luckily I did. If you don't know the plot of `Jane Eyre' I would advise you to brush up on it before reading this book, it will only add to your understanding. Having said that, a synopsis of the plot as it is in the parallel reality is provided 2/3 of the way through the book so it is possible to follow the plot even without knowing `Jane Eyre'.
There are a lot of jokes in the book for those with a wide knowledge of literature. There are also jokes to do with science and a great many other subjects to keep those with little or no knowledge of literature amused. No one is going to get every joke, but that definitely shouldn't put anyone off.
If like me you like a clever read and you are willing to leave your sense of reality behind for the duration then I would definitely recommend this book to you. I was impressed and I can't wait to pick up the next book in the series. As Fforde's writing style becomes more settled and the world he creates becomes more recognisable to the reader, his books can only get better.
|
|
One trick pony...
|
Hmmm.
This was a book that I read for a book club, and it was recommended to me as both "hilarious" and "really clever". Now, I readily admit that I rarely laugh out loud at books, except for Carl Hiaasen and Owen Meanie.
I'll grant you, Fforde has a clever initial idea, and a fairly engaging style. The book bops along at a reasonable pace, and nothing really jars, or holds you up. In that sense, it's an hours-filler. However, once you get past page five, you've understood the basic idea; after that, it becomes a one-trick pony. The "amusing" names are, at best, amusing only once. The time disruption moves quickly from mildly entertaining, to overly-long and slightly annoying.
Generally, this book slips across the line from quirky fun, to a bit clever-clever. It's like an Oxbridge graduate who uses pun after pun in everyday conversation - in short order, it becomes aggravating. Ultimately, it runs out of steam, as Thursday actually goes into the novel, and the whole thing peters out. This is odd, and slightly inexcusable - Fforde has invented a parallel universe, and can take it anywhere he wants. Creativity and imagination should not fizzle out under those circumstances.
Overall, this is an initial idea that runs out of legs. I can't really think what he has put in subsequent novels, that would differ significantly from what he's put in this - and there isn't enough in this for a full novel.
|
|
|