Missing the deadline were we?
|
. I have liked the mixture of archaeology and space exploration since reading Arthur C Clarkes Rama series many years ago. Although this book was good, it was not in the same league as one of Clarkes.Archaeologists are excavating an important site on a planet that is due to be terra-formed. Planet Earth is an eco-disaster area and mankind needs to move out. But the universe is not empty of life. Primitive cultures still exist on another world and there are the remains of some major space faring civilisations around scattered around the galaxy. There is also growing evidence of a pattern of repetitive disasters, of biblical proportions, on several planets that appears to destroy whole civilisations. The hunt is on to follow the clues, discovered at the archaeological sites and subsequently interpreted, to discover the cause of the disasters, whether any of these civilisations have survived and if there are any implications for Earth. I was rather enjoying the first part of the book. There was a mixture of intrigue and drama with slow character building but it all stops half way through when the story shifts to another planet. Here the story seems to speed up and gets shallower. Some of the drama is absurd because of the blatant stupidity of the characters involved. The science is also shaky. I started thinking that this book was to be one of a series, the first in a trilogy perhaps. But when the pace sped up in the second half, I got the sinking feeling that the conclusion was coming. It is a good story but too rushed at the end. Shame.
|
|
Seek us by the light of the horgon's eye
|
|
I hold Jack McDevitt's writing in high regard and always enjoy his science fiction epics a great deal. While his writing has become somewhat formulaic, The Engines of God provides further proof that the man knows how to tell a good story. This novel is the first to feature renowned pilot Priscilla Hutchinson ("Hutch"), a character who has been involved in more grand missions and suffered some of the most globally cursed misfortunes of any character in the universe. This story is built around the mysterious Monument Makers. Saturn's moon Iapetus houses the first such monument discovered by mankind, a mysterious, winged ice sculpture bearing an indecipherable inscription; its existence fuels the search for more monuments, of which a good dozen are located throughout the galaxy. Following in the footsteps of the unknown cosmic entities is as close as mankind has come to interacting with intelligent life elsewhere. On earth, the ecology has progressed beyond the point of no return, and man is looking outward for new earths to be populated. One possible site is Quaraqua, whose civilization has already collapsed. The Academy struggles to learn all they can about this society underneath the waters of the planet at a site dubbed the Temple of the Winds. Hutch is sent to evacuate the scientists before a terraforming project destroys whatever priceless knowledge lies hidden in the watery depths. For me, this first section of the book was the most exciting. Afterwards, having detected a radio signal, Hutch and several others journey to a more distant system, following the path left by the Monument Makers. They finally end up on yet a third planetary body seeking factual data on the mystical "engines of God" alluded to in alien scripts discovered and interpreted along the way. For me, the plot started to collapse in on itself slightly in the second half of the book. On moons orbiting the important sites they visit are huge, fake cities (dubbed Oz) laid out in obsessively straight lines and right angles which have suffered serious charring at times of planetary catastrophe from an unknown source. Apparently, the inexplicable cosmic force they eventually get a look at has an innate attraction to linear geometries-this part of the story, which becomes very important toward the end, seemed a little ludicrous to me. Another thing that bothers me is that, aside from Hutch, the other characters who survived until the end seemed to be the least important and inscrutable of the bunch. McDevitt has no qualms about sacrificing major characters at any time and any way; it's refreshing to see an author do that, but it is sometimes slightly frustrating to finally get to know a character and then see him/her dispensed with rather arbitrarily. This leads to another weakness in the novel. I did not think the character development was very good, especially that of Hutch. McDevitt always seems to want to add a touch of romance and smoldering desires to his books, and in this case it detracts from my admiration from Hutch. She is a brave, heroic woman, yet she can't go on a mission anywhere in the universe, it seems, without at least one former or hopefully future love interest. McDevitt just doesn't handle this type of emotional content well here, and it detracts somewhat from a great story. I think this book made McDevitt a better writer. The flaws that seem to stand out in this effort are much less prominent in his later novels. I felt pretty good about this particular plot up until the fourth and final section; at that point, some of the science seemed to fall apart, and the ultimate conclusion comes off as somewhat improbable and anticlimactic. Some of the decisions made on all sides along the way are incredibly criminal and oftentimes juvenile, and the same mistakes (such as the continued exploration of alien worlds with little or no weapons) have a way of repeating themselves over and over again. I remained incapable of buying into the supposed purpose for the strangely hewn alien Oz sites, and since the final section's activity was based around a scientific interpretation of those sites' significance, the final pages left me somewhat nonplussed. Flawed as this novel is, though, it is certainly a science fiction adventure worth taking. Hutch is a fascinating character whose richness does not really come through in these pages as it does in the follow-up novels Deepsix and Chindi, but this is a more than worthy introduction to her noble character. Sometimes I feel like McDevitt is taking me somewhere I have already visited with him in the past, but I am more than happy to follow him each and every time.
|
|
Great Potential
|
|
This book is almost Tolkien-esque in the way it alludes to, and gives tantalizing hints about a far off past that has been irrevocably lost. It does not however, go into more detail than is (seemingly) necessary to drive the rapidly developing storyline. While this provides a fast ride, the reader is left yearning for more information about McDevit's mysterious universe. The main story line kept my interest in that it focuses on characters that aren't the usual "space-professionals". We aren't given too much to go on concerning their inner workings or backgrounds however - the story being fast paced and characterizations more dialogue-driven than descriptive. I eagerly awaited the return to "The Engines of Gods" central puzzle in the follow-up, Deepsix, only to be disappointed to find that the glimpses of lost civilisations - and the fascinating galaxy-wide drama we take part in "The Engines of God" is more or less treated as a footnote. Major frustration. Let's hope McDevit begins to tie up some of the intriguing loose ends concerning his "lost civilisations", why they really disappeared and what it all means for his alternate "future history" - in some future effort!
|
|
More spacey fun from McDevitt
|
|
This is best of McDevitt's books that i have read. We have his standard small group of intrepid travellers (too small and too intrepid really, but it makes them fun to read about) charging between the stars in pursuit of a hunch that something big is happening and that we need to know about it. They're right of course, and in the face of (the usual) political interference all is ultimately revealed. Okay, it isn't really - The book is quite long already and would have to be one of those tedious great trilogies in order to have space to offer a full explanation. This is a failing really, and prevents the book from becoming more than a decent page-turner - it is certainly that, although some action set-pieces do have a feeling of having been stuffed in to hot the pace up ('hmm, the plot is sagging, lets put everybody in deadly peril for a bit'). Read it anyway though.
|
|
Entire plot could be written up in three chapters
|
|
I can't shake the feeling that this book is meant to be part of a trilogy or that I've just read the first three chapters of a sci-fi book. Unfortunately 380 pages is much too long for a very badly developed central theme. Too many cliched themes (bipedal, sexy aliens), no fresh ideas, the plot plods along, character motivations are shallow, the view of future world history is patently absurd, many themes are left unexplored and the final plot twist clearly leaves the way open for a sequel. I can't shake the feeling that Arthur C. Clarke or Asimov would have taken the idea and turned it into a short story in their pulp days. As a final note, the title is patently absurd and bears no relation to the subject matter. Fairly competent writing earns this book 2 stars from me.
|
|
|